Harvard Won't Divest from Fossil Fuels - But We Don't Understand the Rationale at All

By Celsias

Posted on Oct. 7, 2013. Listed in:

Harvard University, the world’s richest school, has refused to  sell its investments in fossil-fuel companies despite  pressure from students to do so. President Drew Faust of the University has released a letter that says 

divest“I do not believe, nor do my colleagues on the Corporation, that university divestment from the fossil fuel industry is warranted or wise,” Faust said in the letter  , referring to Harvard Corporation, the school’s governing board. “The endowment is a resource, not an instrument to impel social or political change.”

The letter says 

I believe there are a number of more effective ways for Harvard both to address climate change and to enhance our commitment to sustainable investment. 

Our teaching and research on environmental and climate issues is significant and growing, and it is a priority in The Harvard Campaign.

We offer some 250 courses in the broad domain encompassing environmental studies and energy.  We support some 225 faculty who work in the area, as well as a graduate consortium that involves more than 100 students and seven Schools.divest

We have a thriving University Center for the Environment.  Outstanding faculty in chemistry, biology, earth and planetary sciences, engineering, and beyond are making profoundly important contributions to envisioning the future of energy and shaping the relevant science and technology.  The Kennedy School’s Belfer Center has won international acclaim for its influential work on climate change economics and policy.  Harvard scholars in design are on the frontier of thinking about sustainable cities; scholars in law, business, economics, and public policy are leaders in addressing regulatory, commercial, and economic aspects of energy and the environment; scholars in public health do vital research on environmental health and its relation to energy use.  Indeed, the foundation of our current national clean air regulations was a study undertaken more than two decades ago by faculty at the Harvard School of Public Health.

We also have a strong institutional commitment to sustainability in how we live and work.  Our Office for Sustainability is doing outstanding work.  We are making substantial progress in reducing our greenhouse gas emissions.  We have become much more conscious of sustainable design principles in all of our physical planning and construction.  We have created awards to recognize “heroes” who are helping to make Harvard green.  And Harvard has earned an array of honors to recognize various sustainability efforts.  I am very proud of all that our students and faculty and staff are doing on this front, and those efforts will continue and grow. 

harvardAs a long-term investor, we need to strengthen and further develop our approach to sustainable investment.  This is no small undertaking, and it will present challenges along the way.  Especially given our long-term investment horizon, we are naturally concerned about environmental, social, and governance factors that may affect the performance of our investments now and in the future.  Such risks are complex, often global in nature, and addressing them effectively often entails collaborative approaches.  Generally, as shareholders, I believe we should favor engagement over withdrawal.  In the case of fossil fuel companies, we should think about how we might use our voice not to ostracize such companies but to encourage them to be a positive force both in meeting society’s long-term energy needs while addressing pressing environmental imperatives.  And, like other investors, we should consider how to obtain further, better information on how companies not only in the energy industry but across all sectors take account of sustainability risks and opportunities as part of their business strategies and practices."

Really strange response we think . If they care that much about climate change why on earth would they invest in fossil fuels ?

We don't get it !

 

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • Featured project

    View now ›

    Sponsors

    Featured organisation

    View now ›